Personalisation has become a buzzword in marketing, and for good reason. Customers expect tailored experiences that make them feel understood, valued, and catered to. When done well, personalisation strengthens connections with your audience, increases engagement, and drives conversions.
Yet, many businesses miss the mark. Instead of creating meaningful, relevant experiences, their attempts at personalisation feel generic or forced—ultimately alienating the very customers they’re trying to win over.
The problem is not the concept of personalisation itself but the way it’s often executed. True personalisation requires understanding your customers, their needs, and where they are in their journey.
It’s not just about inserting a first name into an email subject line or showing “recommended products” based on broad categories. Customers are savvy, and shallow attempts at personalisation often come across as gimmicky, making them feel like just another data point in your marketing software.
Take, for example, the common scenario of a visitor landing on your website for the first time. Instead of being greeted with a tailored experience that speaks to their needs, they’re bombarded with irrelevant pop-ups, generic recommendations, or ads for items they’ve already purchased.
This isn’t personalisation—it’s noise. When the messaging doesn’t align with their intent or feels disconnected from their actions, customers disengage. Worse, they might feel like you’re guessing instead of truly understanding who they are.
One of the most glaring mistakes businesses make is relying on assumptions instead of actionable data. Just because a visitor clicks on a product doesn’t mean they’re ready to buy it.
They might still be researching or comparing options. Showing aggressive sales messages, like “Buy Now!” without understanding their intent, can backfire. Personalisation isn’t about pushing customers toward your goals—it’s about meeting them where they are and guiding them naturally toward the next step.
Another common pitfall is overgeneralizing your audience. Many businesses segment their customers into overly broad categories, assuming everyone within a segment shares the same preferences or needs.
This approach leads to irrelevant messaging that fails to resonate on an individual level. For example, a customer who buys running shoes might receive promotions for marathon training gear, but if they were shopping for a gift, this message will feel completely off base. Instead of feeling understood, the customer feels overlooked.
The timing of your messaging also plays a critical role in effective personalisation. Sending a follow-up email promoting an item immediately after a visitor abandons their cart might seem proactive, but if it doesn’t account for their reasons for leaving—like unexpected fees or delivery timeframes—it could feel tone-deaf. Customers don’t just want personalised messaging; they want it delivered at the right moment when it feels helpful rather than intrusive.
Personalisation failures aren’t limited to online interactions. They extend into customer service and support as well. Imagine a customer who reaches out for help after placing an order, only to be asked to repeat information they’ve already provided.
This lack of continuity makes the experience feel impersonal, frustrating the customer and eroding trust. True personalisation extends across every touchpoint, ensuring customers feel recognized and valued throughout their journey.
Impersonal experiences don’t just frustrate customers—they drive them away. When personalisation falls flat, customers perceive your brand as out of touch or insincere. This is particularly damaging in today’s competitive landscape, where customers have countless alternatives. If your competitors are delivering tailored, meaningful experiences and you’re not, your audience won’t hesitate to take their business elsewhere.
So, why are so many businesses struggling to get personalisation right? Often, it’s because they’re trying to do too much without a clear strategy. Personalisation is about quality, not quantity.
It’s better to deliver one truly relevant message than to bombard customers with a dozen shallow ones. Businesses that focus on understanding their audience, rather than overwhelming them with irrelevant content, are the ones that succeed.
Another reason personalisation efforts fail is a lack of integration across platforms. Customers don’t interact with your brand in a single channel—they move between your website, social media, email, and even physical locations. If your personalisation efforts are siloed, the experience feels disjointed.
For example, a customer might receive an email promoting a product they just purchased in-store, leaving them wondering if your business even knows who they are. Consistency is key to making personalisation feel seamless and authentic.
Data is at the heart of effective personalisation, but it’s not enough to simply collect it—you need to use it wisely. Businesses often gather vast amounts of customer data without knowing how to apply it meaningfully.
Personalisation isn’t about having the most data; it’s about understanding the right data and using it to enhance the customer experience. This requires analyzing behaviour patterns, preferences, and purchase history to craft messages that feel relevant and timely.
For example, a customer who frequently browses hiking gear but hasn’t made a purchase might respond well to a personalised email offering a discount on their first order.
On the other hand, a repeat buyer might appreciate loyalty rewards or early access to new products. The key is tailoring your messaging to the individual’s actions and relationship with your brand, rather than taking a one-size-fits-all approach.
If you’re struggling to achieve personalisation, the first step is to shift your focus from what you want to achieve—like more sales or higher engagement—to what your customers need.
This means asking questions like: What problems are they trying to solve? What motivates their actions? What barriers are preventing them from taking the next step? The answers to these questions will guide your personalisation efforts and ensure they’re rooted in genuine value for the customer.
Getting personalisation right is no longer optional. Customers expect it, and when it’s done well, it sets your brand apart in a crowded marketplace. But it’s also easy to get wrong, and the consequences of impersonal experiences can be costly. If your personalisation efforts aren’t driving the results you want, it’s time to rethink your approach.
Download The Friction-Free Marketing Blueprint to explore advanced personalisation techniques and learn how to create experiences that truly resonate with your audience. This comprehensive guide will show you how to move beyond surface-level personalisation and craft strategies that build trust, increase engagement, and drive meaningful results.
Don’t let weak or generic personalisation efforts continue to alienate your customers. Get the eBook today and discover how to turn data into actionable insights that enhance every interaction with your audience. The difference between a forgettable experience and a memorable one starts with understanding your customers—and this guide will show you how to do it right.
Until Next Time
Discover more from Dominus Owen Markham
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.